There is an active discussion online right now about the idea that Gen Z is “stupid”. This stems from studies and standardized tests indicating that this generation significantly underperforms its predecessors on cognitive tasks. Those who are more tech-savvy attribute the problem to AI, whereas others point to devices, claiming that mobile phones and screen time are essentially destroying the brains of young people.
Context Matters
First, we must understand that these tests are somewhat relative. They were designed long ago and focus on a world that may no longer exist. Regarding AI, there might be some truth to the criticism: if we Google everything or ask AI for answers without understanding the subject matter, it likely degrades our cognitive abilities.
Information Quality vs. Quantity
When it comes to devices, there is no inherent difference between reading from a phone or a paper book. The real issue isn’t the device, but the quality of information.
Modern individuals process ten times more information than people did before the internet.
We are overwhelmed by a constant flow of data that we cannot fully process, leading to “cognitive overload”.
Much like “empty calories,” we are consuming “empty information”.
The Dopamine Trap
This generation is highly dependent on dopamine. Consequently, educational and informational content is being redesigned to be short and emotional to trigger a “dopamine boost”. As a content creator, I see this crisis firsthand:
No one reads long-reads or complex articles anymore.
This type of deep content has become the “domain of pensioners”.
Instead of content that forces us to work, think, and form new neural connections, we prefer swiping, gamification, and “infotainment”.
Who is to Blame?
The blame doesn’t lie solely with the younger generation, but with everyone—especially media platforms. These platforms prioritize clicks and views, so they optimize for whatever keeps a user scrolling or “hooked” on a video.
While the tests don’t lie about declining cognitive scores, we are facing a complex shift. I don’t know how to get the younger generation back to reading essays. As an author, I notice that my books are mostly bought by people around age 40, likely because my professional, niche content appeals to my own peers.
Conclusion
This is a massive challenge. The problem isn’t AI or the phone itself; it’s the “twitterized” thinking created by the content we consume. When short videos and 300-character messages become the dominant way to receive information, the mind begins to perceive the world only in these fragmented “frames”. That is the real secret behind the test scores.
Originally published on Sovereign Agentic AI on Substack.